mt-whitelist

Has it ever occurred to anyone to develop an “MT-Whitelist” as a different approach to comment spam than Jay Allen’s excellent MT-Blacklist? As the name suggests, MT-Whitelist would only allow approved URLs to be posted in the comments section of your blog. You could begin with a starter batch of okey-doke URLs and then, with each comment using a new URL, you could choose to add new ones to your list (or not). Given the relatively limited number of different commenters the vast majority of blogs attract, this might be a pretty simple answer to the comment spam problem.

(Yes, it’s Friday night, and I’m at home writing about comment spam solutions. But I can be wild and crazy, too: I just got home from a shopping spree at the book store. My life is a nonstop party.)

Print Friendly

6 thoughts on “mt-whitelist

  1. George, perhaps I’m being dim, but wouldn’t a “whitelist” prevent new commenters from coming on board?
    (re. the name: I’m thinking of Raffi’s version of “Baa baa black sheep”: the second verse is
    “Baa baa white sheep, have you any wool?”
    “Yes M’am, yes M’am, three bags full,
    One for the lady and one for the man,
    And one for the little girl who lives down the lane.”
    “Baa baa white sheep, have you any wool?”
    “Yes M’am, yes M’am, three bags full.”)

  2. I had read about that, Jason. I imagined this as a somewhat less labor-intensive process for the reader/commenter. But the more I think about it, the less I’m sure the whitelist is such a good idea. The number of prohibited URLs is always going to be so much smaller than the number of innocuous ones.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *